Introduction to Structured Interviewing
- What is a structured interview?
- Choose the interview format that suits your process
- A more complete picture of each candidate
- Build your interviews once, use them in any format
- Set up your structured interviews
- Evaluate fairly and reduce bias
- Enhance your interviews with AI (optional)
- Candidate experience
- Learn more
To help you identify the best talent faster, you can run all of your structured interviews within the Criteria platform. Whether your candidates record their answers in their own time, meet your interviewers by phone, online or face-to-face, or talk with an AI Interview Agent, every candidate is asked the same questions and evaluated against the same criteria. This keeps your process objective, fair and reliable.
All your candidate's data - their application, assessment results and interviews - will be in one place, making it easier to evaluate their suitability for the role you are hiring for.
What is a structured interview?
In a structured interview, every candidate applying for a role is asked the same job-relevant questions, in the same order, and each answer is evaluated against predetermined criteria. Unstructured interviews, by contrast, are free-flowing conversations with little or no predetermined structure, which leaves more room for gut-level reactions and unconscious bias.
Research clearly indicates that structured interviews offer twice the predictive validity of unstructured interviews, leading to better hiring decisions and reducing the likelihood of a poor hire. Structure rarely happens by accident: when they are not prompted to write structured questions, around 75% of the questions written by both inexperienced and experienced interviewers are unstructured.

Choose the interview format that suits your process
You can run structured interviews in Criteria in three ways: video, live (including Criteria-hosted real-time interviewing) and AI. In each format, every candidate answers the same questions and you evaluate the answers against the same criteria.
Format | How it works | Scoring options |
Video Interviewing | A one-way (asynchronous) interview. Candidates respond to your questions at a time and place of their choosing, on any device, and your evaluators review the responses whenever it suits them. | Human, Automated (Interview Intelligence) or Hybrid |
Live Interviewing | Your interviewers follow a browser-based interview guide with the candidate, by phone, online or face-to-face, rating each response as they go. | Human |
Real-Time Interviewing | A live interview with the video call built in. Criteria hosts the call alongside the interview guide, and (with candidate consent) can record the interview and provide a transcript and AI insights. Uses the same interview template as Live Interviewing. | Human |
AI Interviews | An AI Interview Agent asks each candidate your questions in a two-way conversation, by voice or chat, at a time that suits the candidate. | Human, Automated or Hybrid |
Video interviews
Live interviews
A more complete picture of each candidate
The more reliable, objective information you have about your candidates, the more confidence you can have in your recruitment decisions. We recommend using 2 or 3 assessments early on to measure aptitude, personality and (if required by the role) skills, Emotional Intelligence, and risk propensity. Based on their results, you can then prioritize which candidates are most likely to fit your requirements and invite them to complete an interview.
When a candidate completes assessments and a video, live or AI interview, Criteria combines their results into a single Talent Signal, so you can sort and filter candidates using the full picture. Interview results are included once the minimum number of evaluators have submitted their ratings.
Build your interviews once, use them in any format
Your Interview Content Library stores the questions and messages you use across your interviews: custom questions you create, a stock library of over 100 questions, and custom and example messages. You then combine them into an interview template for the format you are using, so every candidate has the same structured experience.
For each question you choose how it will be scored:
- Human Scoring: your evaluators rate the response. Best for questions that need context and nuance.
- Automated Scoring: Criteria's Interview Intelligence scores the response. Best for behavioural, situational and experience-based questions.
- Unscored: the question gives you added insight but does not affect the candidate's score.
Mixing scoring types in one template is called Hybrid Scoring. Automated Scoring is available for video and AI interviews, but not for live interviews.

Set up your structured interviews
The process is similar whichever format you choose.
- Build your Interview Content Library with the questions and messages you need.
- Create an interview template for your video, live or AI interview.
- Create your job and add the interview step. You can combine assessments, a video interview, a real-time interview and an AI Interview in the same job.
- Invite your candidates. Candidates complete video interviews and AI Interviews from an invitation email. Live and real-time interviews are scheduled outside the platform, and interviewers and candidates join using their interview links.
- Evaluate. Assigned evaluators, or anyone using an evaluator self-assignment link, rate each response against the same guide.
- Review and share results with your hiring team using score reports and shareable interview links.
Evaluate fairly and reduce bias
Mitigating unconscious bias is one of the most important components of a good structured interview. Criteria's tools help by:
- asking every candidate the same questions and rating them against the same guide;
- letting you hide candidates' videos, personal details and feedback messages, and disguise their voices, in video interviews (these options are not available for AI Interviews);
- showing evaluators' ratings and comments only once everyone has reviewed the responses, so evaluators are not influenced by each other; and
- keeping people in charge of hiring decisions. Criteria's AI supports your evaluators; it does not make hiring decisions for them.
Enhance your interviews with AI (optional)
Criteria uses AI in several ways to make structured interviews faster to run and easier to review.
- Interview Intelligence enhances video interviews with interview transcription and summarisation, AI-assisted question creation, AI-generated evaluation guides (behaviourally anchored rating scales) and Automated Scoring.
- Real Time Interviewing provides a live transcript and, after the interview, an AI-generated summary with key moments, plus an Ask Anything tool that gives strictly factual answers drawn from the transcript. These features are only available if the candidate consents.
- AI Interviews use an AI Interview Agent to conduct the interview itself. A transcript, an AI-generated summary with key moments, plus an Ask Anything tool that gives strictly factual answers drawn from the transcript are provided.
Contact your Customer Success Manager to discuss adding Interview Intelligence to your account.
Candidate experience
Whichever format you choose, your candidates will appreciate a professional, well-organized process in which their potential is evaluated fairly, efficiently and objectively.
- Video: candidates can test their settings and complete a practice question before they begin. They can complete the interview anytime, anywhere, on any device. You can add a welcome video and a branded landing page to showcase your organisation’s culture and identity.
- Live: the interviewer works from a structured guide, so every candidate has a consistent interview.
- Real-Time: candidates join from a link, complete a camera and microphone check, and wait to be admitted. Consent to recording and AI-assisted processing is optional and should never influence your evaluation.
- AI: candidates complete the interview when it suits them, by typing or speaking, and can ask the AI Interview Agent about the role if you allow it.
Learn more
Click on the links below to view more information.
Article | What it covers |
Research clearly indicates that structured, job-relevant interview questions are the best predictors of performance. Our definitive guide shows you how to plan and conduct structured interviews. | |
Introduction Guides | Deliver one-way video interviews that candidates complete anytime, anywhere.
|
Use Criteria AI to transcribe, summarize and automatically score your structured video interviews. | |
Choose from a library of standard questions and messages, or create your own. | |
Set up video, live and AI interview templates to present a consistent structured experience. | |
There are many variables to consider when setting up your job, to ensure it follows your organisation's recruitment process. These How To Guides will step you through the process. | |
Invite candidates to complete interviews and assessments | There are several ways to invite your candidates to complete an assessment, video interview, live interview or AI Interview.
|
Evaluators and Interview Links | Decide how your interviews will be scored and who will evaluate them. Share these guides with your evaluators: |
Completing evaluations | Invite the relevant people to evaluate candidate video interviews or allow evaluators to assign themselves. Conduct a Live Interview: Use the Interview Guide to manage the live interview with your candidate and evaluate their responses. Live Interviewing Quick Guide: Criteria's organizational psychologists have compiled some best practices for using the Interview Guide. |
Mitigating unconscious bias is one of the most important components of a good structured interview. Here are our tips for minimising the risk. | |
Viewing and Reviewing Interviews | Review and evaluate your candidates' interview responses. View the results once the minimum number of evaluators have finalized their evaluations. Viewing and Reviewing Video Interviews Reviewing Live Interview Results Share Candidate Video or AI Interview Links, Responses and Results |
Reports | Criteria offers several different types of report for viewing your candidates' assessment and interview results, including:
|
Find quick answers to some common questions about structured interviewing. |